At VIFreepBreaking NewsEducation NewsGovernment House NewsSt. Croix NewsSt. John NewsSt. Thomas NewsTerritorial AffairsV.I. Legislature

Mapp Rightly Vetoes ‘Unrealistic, Uncomprehensive’ Homeschool Bill Promoted By St. Croix Senators Past and Present

CHILD ABUSE THREAT: Advocates of the homeschool/family prison law are Sen. Novelle Francis (left) U.S. Virgin Islands Homeschoolers President Amy Herrick (middle) and Attorney Scott Woodruff (right).

CHARLOTTE AMALIE — Child safety advocates are hailing the fact that Gov. Kenneth Mapp vetoed the deeply-flawed homeschool/”family prison” law which the Legislature passed in its last session.

The failed Bill 31-0391 was pushed in December by former Rules Committee Chair Kenneth Gittens, who was resoundingly voted out of office just the month before.

“This measure creates substantial issues which will require further review and revisions to ensure that the intent of the bill comports with the protections of our territory’s students and their educational needs,” Mapp said. “This measure as written restricts the Commissioner of the Department of Education from promulgating rules and regulations to regulate homeschooling in the territory.”

But Attorney Scott Woodruff, who testified on behalf of the bill sponsored by Sen. Novelle Francis last year, said that the V.I. Board of Education “seeks to impose burdensome and intrusive homeschool regulations” on the territory, some of which have been in place since 1998.

“The governor and the Senate recognize that the homeschool community earnestly desires a more friendly home school law and that we are committed to achieving this goal,” Woodruff said. “We expect that the bill will be refiled following discussions with various parties, perhaps with slightly different language.”

Mapp said that his primary problem with the failed legislation is that it only requires homeschool students to satisfy the requirements of four courses, “which does not align with the requirements of the V.I. Board of Education.”

“There is nothing in the bill that requires the certification of parents in subject matters and curriculum who endeavor to homeschool their children or to measure the performance of such parents and students,” the governor said. “This bill reduces the educational integrity of learning and standards and permits the home school person to determine what is best to teach and what level of learning the student should achieve.”

But Mapp seemed to hold out hopes that a revised homeschool bill could eventually pass muster if members of the Legislature work with the V.I. Department of Education “and other stakeholders to fine-tune and work on passing a realistic comprehensive homeschooling bill that would meet the necessary benchmarks to insure and maintain student achievement.”

The Coalition for Responsible Education said that many students who are homeschooled leave their households “so woefully undereducated” that they are underqualified even for a fast-food job, because they can barely read or write. And child advocates say the potential for abuse, physical, sexual and psychological nearly quadruples in a homeschool setting where parents are free to educate — or not educate their children as they see fit.

Previous post

Four Illegal Migrants From The Dominican Republic Detained In Puerto Rico By Border Patrol

Next post

USVI Film Commission Hires Location Manager David Doumeng As Its Los Angeles-Based 'Liaison'

The Author

John McCarthy

John McCarthy

John McCarthy is primarily known for his investigative reporting on the U.S. Virgin Islands. A series of reports beginning in the 1990's revealed that there was everything from coliform bacteria to Cryptosporidium in locally-bottled St. Croix drinking water, according to a then-unpublished University of the Virgin Islands sampling. Another report, following Hurricane Hugo in 1989, cited a Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) confidential overview that said that over 40 percent of the U.S. Virgin Islands public lives below the poverty line. The Virgin Islands Free Press is the only Caribbean news source to regularly incorporate the findings of U.S. Freedom of Information Act requests. John's articles have appeared in the BVI Beacon, St. Croix Avis, San Juan Star and Virgin Islands Daily News. He is the former news director of WSVI-TV Channel 8 on St. Croix.


  1. Theresa
    April 18, 2017 at 10:08 PM — Reply

    Apparently the Coalition for Responsible Education has not been privy to the benefits of homeschooling that far surpasses the negatives they purported.

  2. Abraham Kennedy
    April 19, 2017 at 6:44 AM — Reply

    Many students are woefully undereducated? That is absurd. How about the destitute public system with high schoolers who can’t multiply, and graduates who haven’t been reading on level since elementary school at best? This is nothing more than an attempt to bind families into using the public “drop out factory” system. I was homeschooled, and I find it highly offensive that these people would try to paint homeschooling as some kind of child abusing haven. It certainly wasn’t so for me or any of the homeschoolers I know! What about all the bullying/gang presence/abuse they could and do receive in the public system?
    #homeschooled #Ihaveamastersdegree

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *