CHARLOTTE AMALIE — A third suspect in the 1st Stop Gas Station shooting of a local marshal in Estate Thomas has turned himself in to police without incident. James “Gogettah” Nathaniel, 22, of St. Thomas turned himself in to the Richard N. Callwood Command about 11:32 a.m. today, the Virgin Islands Police Department said. Nathaniel was … Continue reading Third Suspect In 1st Stop Gas Station Shooting Turns Himself In To Police Today