66-Year-Old St. Thomas Woman Charged With Draining $60,000 From Man’s Account

CHARLOTTE AMALIE — Police say a sexagenarian St. Thomas woman was arrested Friday after she allegedly made withdrawals over the last several months from an elderly man’s bank account without his permission.

Carmen Henley, 66, was arrested at 8:30 a.m. and charged with obtaining money by false pretenses, grand larceny and opening or reading letters of another, the Virgin Islands Police Department said.

VIPD mugshot of Carmen Henley, 66, of St. Thomas.

Bail for Henley was set at $75,000. Unable to post bail, she was transferred to the Richard N. Callwood Command where she was booked and processed.

St. Thomas, USVI – On March 15, 2022, the Economic Crimes Unit began an investigation into a reported obtaining money by false pretenses case on March 15, 2022, according to the VIPD.

The victim reported that several unauthorized electronic transfers totaling over $60,000.00 was removed from his savings account, the ECU found.

“An investigation into the complaint revealed that monies removed from the victim’s account were transferred into Ms. Carmen Henley’s account,” VIPD Communications Director Glen Dratte said. “As a result, a thorough investigation was conducted and upon conclusion, a warrant was secured for Ms. Henley’s arrest.”

Henley was arrested without incident Friday morning pursuant to an arrest warrant obtained in Superior Court by the ECU, according to Dratte.

She was remanded to the custody of the Bureau of Corrections pending an advice-of-rights hearing scheduled for Monday in the Superior Court of the Virgin Islands.

John F. McCarthy is a veteran journalist in the Caribbean, writing from the "Decision Space" where survival meets the surreal. His reporting steel was tempered by a lineage of legendary editors and broadcasters, including Ed Wynn Brant (The Bomb), Owen Eschenroder (Ann Arbor News), Lynelle Emanuel (BVI Beacon), and Charles Thanas (WSVI-TV). Alongside longtime colleague Kenneth C. "Casey" Clark, McCarthy has navigated the front lines of the territory’s history—from the 1997 volcanic "snow" to every major hurricane since Hugo. Known for leaning out of doorless helicopters to capture the "money shot," McCarthy now edits the V.I. Free Press, providing the essential link between the island's colonial past and its SpaceX future.