Virgin Islands, Puerto Rico Express Outrage Over Possible Cockfighting Ban
SAN JUAN — Congress on Wednesday gave final passage to legislation that would shut down legal cockfights in U.S. territories including the U.S. Virgin Islands and Puerto Rico, ending an institution dating from the colonial era that generates millions of dollars each year.
Opponents of the measure approved by the House said it will have a devastating effect on the islands’ economies, noting that in Puerto Rico alone the cockfighting industry generates some $18 million a year and employs some 27,000 people.
“We’re all going crazy. Everybody is desperate,” said 86-year-old Angel Ortiz, who owns a cockfighting ring in the city of Bayamon. “There are so many people who make a living off of this.”
Puerto Rico Gov. Ricardo Rossello traveled to Washington to demand that the island be excluded, but he arrived too late. Legislators unexpectedly moved up the vote and approved the bill, which already passed the Senate.
Cockfighting in Puerto Rico was first officially recognized in 1770, but the practice was banned after the U.S. invaded the island in 1898. It wasn’t until 1933 that it was declared an official sport and became known as the “gentleman’s sport” because of its honor-based betting system.
In October 2010, Puerto Rico legislators voted in favor of a resolution to protect cockfights, stating they are an integral part of the island’s folklore and patrimony. Officials warn that the ban will lead to unemployment on an island already dealing with a 12-year recession.
“It is a cultural and economic pillar for Puerto Ricans,” Public Affairs Secretary Ramon Rosario said. “In addition to its cultural value, the cockfighting industry is the only source of livelihood for thousands of Puerto Rican families.”
Some critics reject that cockfighting has any cultural value.
Ashley Byrne, associate director with PETA, said in a phone interview that the bill was long overdue and will help protect animals.
“Money and tradition are never an excuse for cruelty,” she said. “We need to make sure that business is keeping pace with our ethics.”
She said most people would be appalled to learn that cockfighting is still legal in U.S. territories.
“In a modern society, forcing animals to fight for their lives is cruel,” she said. “Cockfighting is a horrific blood sport.”
Many in Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands were saddened by approval of the ban, which is expected to go into effect in a year.
Stacey Plaskett, the U.S. Virgin Islands’ non-voting delegate in Congress, said she would continue to fight the bill.
“I believed it to be a tremendous overreach of the federal government, which has not supported other basic needs of the territory,” Plaskett said in a statement.
And people in St. Croix and St. Thomas expressed rage at the possibility that their “culture” might be impeded.
“If you’re not a local born and raised here your opinion on this matter is irrelevant it’s part of the lifestyle of some people some of you like your American football some of us like cockfighting we’ve been doing it before you came and we’ll continue to,” Richie Richardson said on Facebook.
Other opponents of the bill said they would struggle to find other types of work.
Miguel Trinidad, who owns a cockfighting ring in the northern Puerto Rican town of Caimito, said he was stunned by the vote. He recently invested $50,000 cash to rebuild his business after Hurricane Maria.
“Now they say they’re going to shut it down,” he said with a sigh, noting that his father first opened the business 50 years ago. “It makes me very sad.”
Supporters say many people beyond owners of cockfighting rings will be affected. They note that thousands of people are hired to raise the animals, shear them, feed them and shelter them.
Pedro Casillas, administrator of an animal supply store in Bayamon, said he fears having to lay off employees and possibly close his business.
“Food for cocks is what we sell the most,” he said. “It represents three-fourths of our sales.”
But Casillas and Ortiz also think the legislation won’t succeed because the ban will only drive cockfights underground.