‘Most Wanted’ Man Charged With Dousing Car With Gas, Then Lighting It On Fire

FREDERIKSTED — A St. Croix man — formerly on the Virgin Islands Most Wanted List — was arrested for allegedly dousing a car with gasoline and then lighting it on fire, authorities said.

Elvis W. Stapleton, 59, of Grove Place, was arrested Thursday and charged with first-degree arson, the Virgin Islands Police Department said.

VIPD mugshot of Elvis W. Stapleton, 59, of Lorraine Village Apartments on St. Croix

The 911 Emergency Call Center dispatched units at 5:49 p.m., Thursday to Frederiksted where a victim was requesting police assistance with a male individual who was creating a disturbance, according to the VIPD.

Upon Criminal Investigation Bureau detectives’ arrival, they contacted the victim and witnesses who stated that Stapleton took a jerrycan with gasoline in it, poured the gas over a vehicle’s hood and then ignited it, VIPD Communications Director Glen Dratte said.

Stapleton fled the area and subsequently was apprehended by officers with no further incident, according to Dratte.

Bail for Stapleton was set at $75,000. Unable to post bail, he was transported to the John Bell Adult Correctional Facility where he was remanded to the custody of the Bureau of Corrections pending an advice of rights hearing in Superior Court.

Stapleton made the Virgin Islands Most Wanted in early 2009 when he was being sought on a first-degree rape charge, according to police records.

John F. McCarthy is a veteran journalist in the Caribbean, writing from the "Decision Space" where survival meets the surreal. His reporting steel was tempered by a lineage of legendary editors and broadcasters, including Ed Wynn Brant (The Bomb), Owen Eschenroder (Ann Arbor News), Lynelle Emanuel (BVI Beacon), and Charles Thanas (WSVI-TV). Alongside longtime colleague Kenneth C. "Casey" Clark, McCarthy has navigated the front lines of the territory’s history—from the 1997 volcanic "snow" to every major hurricane since Hugo. Known for leaning out of doorless helicopters to capture the "money shot," McCarthy now edits the V.I. Free Press, providing the essential link between the island's colonial past and its SpaceX future.